Sherwin Wine probably would have liked to be recognized as the head of the secular Jewish Sanhedrin. (In case you aren’t familiar with the Sanhedrin: it was the priestly ruling body in ancient Israel, as well as the historically-conscious name of a body of Jewish leaders installed by Napoleon. So it means an official ruling body of Jews – which obviously no secular Jews would recognize if it tried to come back today.)
Personally, I'm a non-organizational secluar Jew. I've met people who belong to the Birmingham Temple, and I find it interesting that he ordained other rabbis of secular Judaism, but in fact, I have more difficulty understanding organized secular Judaism than I have understanding organized religious Judaism. I don't know why you need the temple model to assemble and celebrate culture as opposed to performing religious rituals. My problem.
I love the life cycle ritual and liturgy of secular Humanistic Judaism. It's a bit of the traditions, but not too much.
ReplyDeleteHumanistic Judaism appeals to some with a mild religious background. I get warm and fuzzy feeling and recall my ancestors more vividly and emotionally.